Deal or No Deal? Canada's 77% Problem

Govind Rajan Talluri -

Opening Play

Prime Minister Mark Carney returned from Washington this week without a trade deal. Canada–U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc called the meeting “successful” and “positive,” but offered no tangible outcomes. President Trump told reporters he’s working on a deal Canadians “will love us again” for.

It will be interesting to see what that deal actually looks like — especially after Carney’s pledge of a $1 trillion Canadian investment in the United States. Will there be a similar flow in reverse, from the U.S. into Canada’s infrastructure, clean energy, and technology sectors?

The optics matter less than the reality: Canada walked in seeking relief and walked out promising U.S. investment. For Canadian businesses, the message is clear — don’t wait for political breakthroughs to plan your next move.

This is the moment to reassess Canada’s trade portfolio, understand where leverage exists, and explore strategic options that don’t depend on Washington’s goodwill.

Deal or No Deal? - Canada's 77% Problem - I AM GRT - MightyIQ Inc. - Govind Talluri

Global Play: The 77% Problem

In 2024, Canada exported over $781 billion in goods — with 77% of those exports going to the United States.
That level of concentration has historically provided stability but also exposes Canada to significant vulnerability when trade tensions rise.

When one customer represents such a dominant share of total exports, leverage in negotiations tends to shift — and the need for diversification becomes more urgent.

Canada’s Export Reality

Sector % to U.S. Diversification Status
Energy Products 89% Highly dependent
Automotive 85–90% Highly dependent
Plastics & Chemicals 75–85% Highly dependent
Pharmaceuticals 70–80% Highly dependent
Agriculture 30–40% Most diversified
Metals & Minerals 50–60% Moderately diversified
Critical Minerals 60% (declining) Rapidly diversifying

The sectors that have diversified share common traits: global demand, resource strength, and non-U.S. buyers.

Local Play: Four Strategic Pathways Forward

Waiting isn’t a strategy. When negotiations stall or tariffs persist, diversification becomes necessity.

1. Infrastructure-Enabled Diversification

The Problem: 89% of Canadian energy exports go south because pipelines and ports point only to the U.S.

The Fix:

  • Build LNG export terminals on both coasts to serve Asia and Europe
  • Expand Pacific port capacity for agriculture, forestry, and minerals
  • Develop Arctic shipping routes to reach Europe faster

Target Buyers:

  • Europe: Reduced Russian gas imports (45% → 19%)
  • Japan & South Korea: LNG-dependent economies
  • India: Rising LNG demand amid coal phase-out

Reality Check: Requires $50–100 billion and a decade — but it’s the cost of true sovereignty.

2. Leverage Existing Trade Agreements

Canada already has world-class trade access — but underutilizes it.

CETA (Canada–EU)
→ Tariff-free access to 450 million consumers
→ Best bets: EV components, aerospace, pharmaceuticals, critical minerals

CPTPP (Asia-Pacific)
→ Access to Japan, Vietnam, Australia, Singapore, and others
→ Agriculture exports to Japan already up 39.3% in 2024
→ Best bets: Agri-food, seafood, industrial machinery

Action Point: Fund trade missions, export financing, and market intelligence so SMEs can actually use these corridors.

3. The Value-Added Imperative

Canada exports raw materials, imports finished goods — and loses on both price and leverage.

Raw Export Imported Equivalent Missed Opportunity
Crude Oil Refined Gasoline Refineries & jobs
Lumber Engineered Wood Prefab construction exports
Canola Seed Cooking Oil Packaged food exports
Wheat Pasta & Bakery Food brand value
Lithium Ore Battery Materials EV-supply leadership

Bottom Line: Every step up the value chain multiplies resilience and profit.

4. Critical Minerals: Canada’s Strategic Ace

The EV transition is reshaping global supply chains — and Canada sits on the minerals everyone wants.

Why It Matters:

  • EU, Japan, Korea, and India seek alternatives to China
  • U.S. IRA mandates North American sourcing
  • EU–Canada Critical Minerals Partnership (2023) already signed

Canada’s Advantage: Reserves, stability, ESG standards, and mining expertise.
Next Step: Invest in refining and processing — not just mining. Capture value before it ships.

Strategic Leverage: If the U.S. expects Canadian capital inflows, Canada can expect reciprocal commitments — in battery plants, AI, green hydrogen, and next-gen manufacturing.
Reciprocity, not reliance, builds respect.

Closing Play: Optionality = Leverage

Carney will return to Washington. There’ll be another round of “positive” meetings. But until Canada builds real options, it will continue negotiating from weakness.

Power in trade doesn’t come from goodwill — it comes from economic optionality.

When Canada can say:

  • “Our LNG ships sail to Europe and Asia.”
  • “Our critical minerals supply EU gigafactories.”
  • “Our CETA and CPTPP access rivals U.S. markets.”
  • “Our agri-exports feed Asia’s growth.”
  • “Our factories make value-added products, not just raw goods.”

Then Washington will negotiate seriously.

Because optionality, not dependency, defines true strength.

Beyond Growth Takeaways

✅ Recognize the 77% exposure — overconcentration is risk, not security
✅ Build diversification infrastructure — LNG, ports, Arctic shipping
✅ Leverage CETA & CPTPP — use what’s already in place
✅ Add value at home — refine, process, brand
✅ Play the minerals card smartly — global EV supply chain is open
✅ Stop waiting for politics — build alternatives today, negotiate from strength tomorrow

Final Note: Agriculture Proves It’s Possible

Canada’s agriculture sector diversified through action, not rhetoric.

  • China buys 67% of canola seed ($4B).
  • Japan’s imports grew 39.3% in 2024.

These weren’t diplomatic wins — they were built on quality, reliability, and market focus.

If agriculture can diversify, so can energy, automotive, and manufacturing.
It takes infrastructure, investment, and the courage to accept short-term pain for long-term strength

References

🤝 Let’s Collaborate

I’m an entrepreneur and business growth consultant based in Canada, working at the intersection of CPG, media, and technology.
My focus is on helping businesses scale through:

🌍 International trade & market diversification
📺 FAST channels & media partnerships
💻 Digital transformation & platform adoption
🛒 CPG strategy & consumer insights

As wellness, media, and consumer experiences are being reimagined in today’s unpredictable economy, I believe the real winners will be those who combine value, technology, and conscious choices to build growth that lasts.

🔔 Stay Connected

If these reflections resonate with you, I’d love to continue the conversation.
👉 Subscribe to my newsletter on entrepreneurship, media, AI, and creative growth: iamgrt.kit.com